Our quick choice
Mavis Tires & Brakes
Record checks pending
Strengths
- Rated 4.8 from 2,701 reviews
Trade-offs
- Lowest rating of the four (4.8), still above our bar
- No free estimate listed
Tallahassee tire shops · 4 compared
Compare Tallahassee’s 4 Top Tire shops
Four strong choices, each good at something different. Scan the grid, then get quotes from only the ones you like.
Four Tallahassee tire shops compared
Swipe sideways to compare all 4
| Compare | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 4.8 / 5 | 4.8 / 5 | 4.9 / 5 | 4.9 / 5 |
| Reviews | 2,701 | 1,638 | 114 (2021) | 3,575 |
| Years operating | Not known | Not known | Not known | Not known |
| Services | Not listed yet | Not listed yet | Not listed yet | Not listed yet |
| Price | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published |
| Free estimate | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed |
| Based in | TallahasseeBased here | TallahasseeBased here | TallahasseeBased here | TallahasseeBased here |
| Verified | Not yetCheck pending | Not yetCheck pending | Not yetCheck pending | Not yetCheck pending |
| Best for | Most reviewed | A strong all-round choice | A strong all-round choice | Best overall |
Ratings and reviews from public review sites, checked October 31, 2026.Bars compare the four with each other.Spot a mistake?
Our quick choice
No time to read everything? Start here.
If you call just one
Mavis Tires & Brakes
The strongest overall score of the four: rating, review volume, recent activity, years in business and the checks we could confirm, taken together.
- 2,701 reviews, rated 4.8
- Choose instead if you want another strong optionMavis Tires & Brakes
- Choose instead if you want another strong optionJim Wells Tire Center
- Choose instead if you want another strong optionProctor Subaru
The four, up close
Key facts, strengths and trade-offs for each, so you know what you’re getting.
Strong all-rounder
Mavis Tires & Brakes
Record checks pending
Strengths
- Rated 4.8 from 1,638 reviews
Trade-offs
- Lowest rating of the four (4.8), still above our bar
- No free estimate listed
Strong all-rounder
Jim Wells Tire Center
Record checks pending
Strengths
- Highest rating of the four (4.9)
Trade-offs
- Fewest reviews of the four (114 (2021))
- No free estimate listed
Also in the four
Get quotes from the businesses you choose
Tick one or several. Only the ones you tick will see your request.
Before you sign: five checks
Ask every company for the same scope in writing, then check these.
- Written quote with materials, permit fees and clean-up
- Active state license and insurance
- The company pulls the permit, not you
- Written warranty: what and how long
- Payments tied to finished stages
Costs and more checks: Tallahassee tire shops guide.
How we picked these four
We compare, we don’t sell spots. Every FourBest page follows the same published method.
- 37Tallahassee tire shops passed our basic checks
- 8,028public reviews behind the four we picked
- 4picked, each with a different strength
- $0paid by any business to be included
Local facts: Leon
Public data behind this comparison.
- $294,400Median home value: Median value of owner-occupied homes (ACS table B25077).Public recordU.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates · 2020–2024
- 53.3%Homes built before 1990: 51,828 of 97,245 housing units were built in 1989 or earlier (ACS table B25034, year structure built).Public recordU.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates · 2020–2024
- 85,311Households in Tallahassee: Occupied housing units (one household per occupied home), ACS table B25003.Public recordU.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates · 2020–2024
- June 1 to November 30Atlantic hurricane season: An average season (1991–2020) has 14 named storms, 7 hurricanes and 3 major hurricanes.Public recordNOAA National Hurricane Center, Tropical Cyclone Climatology · 1991–2020 climate period
- 1988Median year homes were built: Half of all housing units were built before this year (ACS table B25035).Public recordU.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates · 2020–2024
- 40.6%Owner-occupied homes: 34,661 of 85,311 occupied homes are lived in by their owners (ACS table B25003).Public recordU.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates · 2020–2024
Figures from public sources, checked October 31, 2026.
More tire shops in Tallahassee
The other 33 companies that passed our basic checks.
| Company | Rating | Reviews | Years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mavis Tires & BrakesTallahassee | 4.8 | 2,142 | – |
| Proctor AcuraTallahassee | 4.8 | 1,554 | – |
| Discount TireTallahassee | 4.5 | 1,016 | – |
| Pep Boys Auto Service & TiresTallahassee | 4.5 | 1,271 | – |
| Peter Boulware Toyota Service CenterTallahassee | 4.5 | 1,152 | – |
| Tire Choice Auto Service CentersTallahassee | 4.7 | 208 (2021) | – |
| Discount TireTallahassee | 4.5 | 636 | – |
| Tallahassee FordTallahassee | 4.4 | 3,178 | – |
| Tire Town Automotive CenterTallahassee | 4.8 | 78 (2021) | – |
| The Tire Centre of FloridaTallahassee | 4.6 | 148 (2021) | – |
| Real Deal Custom Wheels and TiresTallahassee | 4.8 | 56 (2021) | – |
| Capital VolkswagenTallahassee | 4.9 | 56 (2021) | – |
| Tire Town & MufflerTallahassee | 4.6 | 97 (2021) | – |
| Auto Xperts Monroe - a Main Street Auto shopTallahassee | 4.6 | 95 (2021) | – |
| Boulevard Tire CenterTallahassee | 4.9 | 33 (2021) | – |
| Precision Tune Auto CareTallahassee | 4.4 | 215 (2021) | – |
| Neece Tire and Auto ServiceTallahassee | 4.4 | 113 (2021) | – |
| Tire KingdomTallahassee | 4.3 | 186 (2021) | – |
| B & B TiresTallahassee | 4.6 | 68 (2021) | – |
| Big A's Tire & WheelTallahassee | 4.4 | 163 (2021) | – |
| Furrin Auto AlleyTallahassee | 4.4 | 53 (2021) | – |
| Pep Boys Auto Service & TiresTallahassee | 4.2 | 138 (2021) | – |
| Westside Tire and BrakeTallahassee | 4.2 | 118 (2021) | – |
| Big A's Tires SouthTallahassee | 4.3 | 115 (2021) | – |
| Jose's Tire & Car ServiceTallahassee | 4.4 | 54 (2021) | – |
| Pep Boys Auto Service & TiresTallahassee | 4.1 | 174 (2021) | – |
| Firestone Complete Auto CareTallahassee | 4.1 | 156 (2021) | – |
| Tires PlusTallahassee | 4.1 | 146 (2021) | – |
| Thompson Services Of Tallahassee LLCTallahassee | 4.6 | 13 (2021) | – |
| Pep Boys Auto Service & TiresTallahassee | 4.1 | 118 (2021) | – |
| Barrons Wholesale TireTallahassee | 4.3 | 14 (2021) | – |
| Tire KingdomTallahassee | 4.0 | 86 (2021) | – |
| Affordable TiresTallahassee | 4.0 | 18 (2021) | – |
FAQ: tire shops in Tallahassee
How is the top 4 ranking of tire shops in Tallahassee calculated?
Each business gets a score from its rating, review volume, recent reviews, years in business, profile completeness and record checks. The highest scores make the list. We compared 37 tire shops for Tallahassee. Paid placements never change the order.
Which of these tire shops in Tallahassee has the best reviews?
Proctor Subaru has a 4.9 rating from 3575 public reviews, the highest on this page.
Are these tire shops licensed?
We are still checking licenses for this list. Before you hire, look the business up on the state licensing board's website.
How many quotes should I get for tire shops in Tallahassee?
Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request.
Own a business in Tallahassee?
Claim your free profile to check your facts, add your services and see when homeowners compare you. It takes about five minutes.